Featured: New Book: Astrometrology: The Science of Ancient Metrology by Christopher Willett

New Book: Astrometrology: The Science of Ancient Metrology by Christopher Willett

Random Image

Visiting the Past: Finding and Understanding Britain's Archaeology

Visiting the Past: Finding and Understanding Britain's Archaeology

Login

Register here - as a registered user you get more features and fewer ads.

Who's Online

There are currently, 1164 guests and 8 members online.

Sponsors

Comment Post

Re: Skeptic as Dowser by Lynne_Kelly on Tuesday, 22 November 2011

A very interesting article, with my name listed as a successful dowser. I must point out that I am a sceptic, using a pendulum, and registered for this as such. As the author of 'The Skeptic's Guide to the Paranormal' (a chapter of which is on dowsing) and doing a doctorate taking a very pragmatic approach to interpretation of non-state non-literate archaeological sites, I must explain!

I use a pendulum a lot in doing magic tricks and public performances explaining the ideomotor response (the innate muscular movements that will cause a pendulum to move on thinking about it without you being conscious of the fact you are actually causing the movement). I have no doubt that the pendulum moving over that square (as it did) was a result of my identifying that square as the most likely - and not anything to do with some kind of psychic response. I have a strong ideomotor response and can make a pendulum swing in any direction by thinking that way. In experiments I have done with dowsers, and other paranormal claims, I have been able to replicate anything claimants have been able to do - including very accurate psychic readings - WITHOUT using any paranormal means. I use rational reasoning.

So please keep my name firmly on the sceptical end of the spectrum - but as a true sceptic - happy to be convinced otherwise by evidence produced under test conditions.
Fun debate! Thanks, Andy!
Lynne Kelly

Something is not right. This message is just to keep things from messing up down the road