Featured: Exploring Avebury: The Essential Guide - New Expanded Edition!

Exploring Avebury: The Essential Guide - New Expanded Edition!

Inscribed Across the Landscape: The Cursus Monuments of Great Britain

Inscribed Across the Landscape: The Cursus Monuments of Great Britain

Login

Register here - as a registered user you get more features and fewer ads.

Who's Online

There are currently, 1400 guests and 1 members online.

Sponsors

Comment Post

Re: A New Dimension to Ancient Measures by Dr Thomas Gough and Peter Harris by STOCKDALE on Saturday, 27 November 2021

Book review: Dr. Thomas Gough and Peter Harris ‘A New Dimension to Ancient Measures ' by Chris Snook, Archaeology Plus Ltd.

The authors fully acknowledge their debt to Alexander Thom, who revolutionised the study of megalithic structures in Britain and France with his series of books, (one with his son Archie). The Megalithic Yard was Thom’s bombshell deduction, with the battle for recognition still running after 40 years. Euan Mackie, using sites in Scotland, broadly concurs with Thom’s claims. In contrast, Clive Ruggles’ re-evaluation of Thom’s fieldwork made him suggest that Thom’s ‘millimetre accuracy’ claims were not substantiated.

The same problems arise for the new definition of the ‘Harris Stockdale Megalithic Foot’, or HSMF, which it is claimed by the authors allows for the application of basic geometry to create the key aspects of circles devoted to lunar and/or solar measurements. It is relatively easier to get accurate dimensions for the Great Pyramid of Cheops/Khufu due to the high precision of finishing of the casing stones, than it is at sites using unshaped or roughly shaped blocks of stone, such as the megalithic structures under consideration here.

I was impressed by the relatively simple geometric constructions related to multiples of the HSMF and to the seeming relevance of the unit to Newgrange at the bend of the Boyne. The consideration of the decorated stones on Rombalds Moor near Ilkley was also fascinating. I am not a mathematician or statistician and Harris writes that the authors also felt deficient in this field, so got the services of two people qualified to analyse the datasets and to report back on the likelihood of the authors’ assertions being valid – which they apparently are.

Conclusions: The conclusions are similar to my layman’s doubts about the transmission of relatively complex concepts and mind-tools from a literate to non-literate society, speaking different languages and with different social concepts, 6000 years ago. Add in the ability to conserve the accuracy of the data for over 1000 years and it sounds like an improbability. However, taking the two examples known to be accurate accounts of such events, i.e. the Icelandic acquisition of Law from Norway in a verbal form passed down through generations in the Viking period, and Captain Cook’s account of a Polynesian navigator/ genealogist, who carried seven days accumulated knowledge in his head. Only a few people in any generation are likely to have such acute memories and were no doubt selected young and trained up.

In conclusion, an interesting addition to the discipline of archaeoastronomy and well worth a read.

Chris Snook
(Amateur archaeologist for 50 years and professional dealer in archaeology books)
Archaeology Plus Ltd
+44 1323 507712

Authors footnote. The Sumerian foot of 13.2 inches, 1.1 feet found its way as the 'Northern Foot' via the Germanic tribes to England as the Saxon foot and eventually became our 12" foot.

"A NEW DIMENSION TO ANCIENT MEASURES
Thomas Gough & Peter Harris
Moravian Press, 2021. 76pp, £15. 978-1-9196484-0-8
Available at The Megalithic Portal bookshop or from Peter Harris at :
[email protected].

Something is not right. This message is just to keep things from messing up down the road