Featured: Please Sign the Petition: Amend the Ancient Monuments Act to ban all building on Scheduled Sites

Please Sign the Petition: Amend the Ancient Monuments Act to ban all building on Scheduled Sites

Random Image

Art as Metaphor: The Prehistoric Rock-art of Britain

Art as Metaphor: The Prehistoric Rock-art of Britain

Login

Register here - as a registered user you get more features and fewer ads.

Who's Online

There are currently, 1365 guests and 2 members online.

Sponsors

Comment Post

Re: How 7,000-year-old temples reveal the elaborate culture of Europe by Anonymous on Tuesday, 14 June 2005

Dear Sir/Madam,

Please find below some extracts from the archaeological biography I am writing on a scholar by the name of L.A. Waddell (1854-1938) and the result of research in the ancient history department, the University of Wales Swansea, as they may offer clues to some of the mysteries of the oldest civilisation discovered across Central Europe. Waddell was a philologist who studied Sumerian and Sanskrit for 25 years and who directed excavations at Pataliputra, India. I have been identifying his contemporary reception and the evolution of the consensus from his time to the present in regard to his research, including the question of Indo-European origins. The matter of Aryan origins has embarrassing connotations for scholars because the Nazi regime used this terminology, but Aryan really means 'Indo-European' and although Waddell also used this term, he did so in the 1920s and was not the only British scholar to do so. Waddell specialised in research in relation to the Aryans (Indo-European origins in race and language). Society was patriarchal for the Indo-Europeans, and there is evidence (referred to in the text below) that they settled down among an older matriarchal culture (refer to Marija Gimbutas' theories below) and contributed to its disappearance. (Please excuse the fact that my footnotes to acknowledge sources have disappeared when I pasted the extracts in this window).

When I read David Keys' article in The Independent (11/06/05) and that by Cahal Milmo, I was particularly interested in the statements that 'the people who built the circular temples were descendants of migrants who arrived many centuries earlier from the Danube plain' and that the ditches were not for defensive purposes. I believe the object of these ditches may have been to keep the rituals secret. This belief is based on the following data: In India, the Aryans had a social system with privileged classes, such as that of the Brahmans. According to another scholar, E.B.Havell, this system was a revival of the original archaic system of caste exclusiveness after a shift of notions had occurred: from a purely physical interpretation of right of birth to a spiritual one (right to the caste by initiation and spirituality). If the oldest civilisation that has been discovered is that of the proto-Indo-Europeans, like their blood kinsmen in India or separate branch which emigrated from North Syria, the builders of the circular temples may have wanted to prevent lower classes or the indigenous matriarchal people surrounding them from gaining a knowledge which was reserved to initiates or higher members of the Aryans, and from seeing secret rituals conducted in the inner sanctum of the temples. E.B. Havell suggested that the Aryans did not manage to preserve their bloodline as they inter-married with the matriarchal indigenous population. I wonder whether the same thing could have happened to the Aryans of Central Europe and whether this could explain why they lost the ability to build their temples after 200 years.

First extract:
''In a very remote time, it was at first necessary to be born Aryan to be a member of the upper class (or Aryan), but later, access to it could be acquired by initiation into the class. There were distinctive differences as indeed Aryans were patriarchal but the indigenous population of India had mostly adhered to a matriarchal system until it was exposed to the British rule. Overall, the vision that emerges about the Aryans is that they possessed a profound knowledge of life and as pointed out by Waddell, were inventors of agriculture, irrigation, dams, architecture, of the Bronze Age, of customs such as ‘marriage’, and they were monogamous, and also of astronomical observatories, astrology, etc. According to E.B. Havell, knowledge was guarded from unscrupulous adversaries lest it should be perverted or made a weapon. Craft and writing may have been handed down as an initiation for the same reason. In addition, they even created a class of guardians that was trained for the task of protecting the race and secrets of knowledge. Not only were the Kshatriyas in possession of knowledge, they were its watchful keepers sworn to preserve the Aryan bloodline or royal blood. Originally the Brahmans were attendants to the Kshatriyas at tribal sacrifices where hymns were chanted. They were in charge of vessels which may also relate to the Indo-European Grail legend and mysteriously to the ‘soma’ (possibly an elixir of life). The Brahmans ultimately obtained precedence over the Kshatriyas but at this time the privilege of performing sacrificial rituals was not acquired by birth any more but by a ceremony which invested them with power: an initiation into the sacred thread, ‘Brahma-charin’ or studentship. The Guru whispered a mystic formula, the Gayatri, the essence of the Vedas (Manu ii:157). The initiate was then required to abstain from sensual excesses, to observe rules of hygiene and of purity of mind and body, speak the truth, control his passions, keep from harming animals, etc. (Manu iv). But Brahmans who committed sins were despised in this life and the next (Manu iv:199). The title 'Manu’s Land and Trade Laws: their Sumerian Origin and Evolution up to the beginning of the Christian era', by R.S. Vaidyanatha Ayyar, published by Higginbothams, Madras, 1927, was in Waddell’s personal library and is now held in the Special Collections of Glasgow University. This work appears to support the Sumerian origin of Indian laws. ''

Second extract:
Modern views in Indo-European studies:
The Indo-Europeans are believed to have spoken the parent language of the family of Indo-European languages in various parts of Europe as a result of migration. The general view about the origin of the Indo-Europeans today, as represented in 'The Seventy Great Mysteries of the Ancient World ' is the family of Indo-European languages derived from a Proto-European language which is traceable backward in time from Ireland to the Tocharians in Western China. Scholars have been attempting to solve this mystery for two centuries. The approach in the field of the origin of Indo-European languages is now that the languages ancient Indo-Europeans spoke derived from a hypothetical common ancestral tongue. The exploration of their origin entails the reconstruction of the Indo-European prototype. Researchers involved in ‘Projects Tied’ are working on the Tocharian as well as Anatolian, the two eastern branches of language which according to Colin Renfrew, are the most worthy of investigation. The reconstruction of the proto-Indo-European language was boosted by the discovery of the ancient Hittite (Khatti or Hatti) or Anatolian language of Turkey – which confirmed F. Saussure’s assumptions that segments of the proto language which did not suvive were laryngeal.

It is generally accepted that as the original Indo-Europeans migrated across Eurasia during the Neolithic and Early Bronze Age, differences gradually appeared in their language and as in the biblical story of the Tower of Babel, they began to be unable to understand each other. However, scholars have been able to determine what family of languages a language belongs to by the examination of a range of its vocabulary. For instance, in Tocharian the term ‘trai’ resembles ‘thrie’ in Old English, ‘tres’ in Italic Latin, ‘treis’ in Greek, ‘tri’ in Indic Sanskrit, ‘tri’in Celtic Old Irish, ‘trys’ in Baltic Lithuanian, ‘trije’ in Slavic russian and ‘trois’ in French. They explain such similarities by the existence in antiquity, as far back as c.7,000-3,000 B.C. of an ancestral spoken language common to each one. The Tocharian region of the oasis towns of the Silk Road discovered by M.A. Stein in Western China is the most ancient area that research has traced the Indo-European languages back to. It has also been the aim of philologists who have been engaged in this pursuit, to attempt to reconstruct some of the vocabulary of Proto-Indo-European. They have identified the distribution of the major Indo-European languages groups. They believe that Iberian in Spain, Etruscan in Italy, and Hattic in Anatolia, were non-Indo-European languages and know for sure that Indo-European spread like waves of invasion and influenced non-Indo-European languages spoken by indigenous populations in some areas. The Elamites in Southern Iran were assimilated by Iranians. It is assumed that the Indo-Aryans imposed their language onto the earlier Dravidians and Munda people in the Indus Valley. It is possible that non-Indo-European ancient languages have disappeared because of the spread of the Indo-Europeans. One such language has survived in Europe. It is called ‘Basque’ and is spoken in Northern Spain and Southern France. The area which the Indo-Europeans appear to have spread over in antiquity stretches from the Atlantic Ocean to Western China.

There are three main schools of thought today as regards the homeland of Indo-Europeans (but these may have to be reviewed in view of the discovery hailed as Europe's oldest civilisation). According to the first model, the Proto-Indo-Europeans’ point of origin may be found in Eurasia, before the Neolithic, and either during the Palaeolithic or Mesolithic ages. Eurasia is situated north of Anatolia and Turkey. The idea is that they would have migrated slowly from a very remote time, reducing the distance to account for as regards each generation. However, it is not regarded as an acceptable model because it does not take into account the shared late Neolithic vocabulary discovered through reconstruction of the proto-language. In the second theory, the expansion of the Indo-Europeans is linked to agriculture, the economy and innovation of the Indo-European civilization (the civilisation of the temples was pastoral). Farmers would have gradually replaced indigenous hunters. This school of thought reaches the conclusion that the Indo-Europeans’ earliest homeland was Anatolia (ancient Turkey) between 7,000-3,000 B.C. (Waddell expounded that the earliest civilisation in Cappadocia may have originated from an area north of the Danube). The two models referred above also include an expansion from Anatolia into Greece and the Balkans and then westwards. The third theory relies on ‘social shift’ instead of population movement and situates the origin of the Indo-Europeans in the Northern steppes of Russia. Their area of settlement would not have been as spread as Eurasia but more concentrated north of the Black & Caspian seas. These are sometimes referred to as the Kurgan people.

Other findings which may be regarded as leading to similar conclusions (as Waddell's) are those at archaeological sites excavated by Professor Marija Gimbutas, which have permitted her to assess that Proto-Indo-Europeans were a patrilineal, pastoral and semi-nomadic group of peoples who originated in the steppes of Russia. She identified them as 'the Kurgan culture'. She said they were militaristic, used weapons and rode horses. They had a rudimentary agriculture and developed metallurgy. They migrated to Greece, Italy, Britain, Germany, Scandinavia, Anatolia (Cappadocia), India, Iran and the Chinese Turkestan, in three waves, the second of which (dated circa 3400-3200 B.C.) is relevant to L.A. Waddell's theories as regards the Sumerians' origin from Cappadocia and before their settling down in the latter, from a region north of the Danube. In the 1960s, after studying ethnic processes beyond the 2nd Millennium B.C., Professor P. Bosch-Gimpera also theorised about the migration of Indo-European dolichocephals or Nordic type (blonds with white skin and blue eyes). South Russia was identified by V.Gordon Childe as the place of origin of the ‘Urheimat’ or Indo-European people whom Marija Gimbutas refers to as the Kurgan people. While Philologists such as Childe believed these people came from the West (Germany or Poland), on the basis of outdated linguistic grounds, Marija Gimbutas’ model for the origin of the Kurgan people who introduced an early Indo-European language to Russia was from the East on the basis of more recent archaeological discoveries and opinion putting the Indo-European homeland in the Lower Volga steppes and area east of the Caspian Sea. Archaeologists have discovered a change in the racial population of South Russian skeletal remains c.4,500 B.C., showing that a genetically distinct people intruded the area, mixed with the natives, and was assimilated even before their language reached the West of Europe. According to Marija Gimbutas, these ‘dolichomesocranial’ newcomers (or dolichocephalic with narrow faces or Strednij Stog-2 men, but also Cro-Magnon) were taller in stature and of a more gracile type than the indigenous substratum population (massive Cro-Magnons or Dniepr-Donets people, present there from the Upper Palaeolithic period). It has been observed that this new racial type of the first Kurgan community (which is believed to be Indo-European) is similar to the tall and long-headed type of people of some parts of contemporary India and Pakistan, as well as the Harappan and pre-Harappan remains. The material examined for the period of 4,000 to 3,500 B.C. point to a co-existence of the two racial types which were both of Cro-Magnon C type, with different burial practices, being collective in respect of the more robust Cro-Magnons, and single burials in respect of the more gracile Kurgan ones, even in the same villages. These findings agree with those of geneticists like L.Cavali-Sfarza confirming one another’s theory that the migration of Indo-European occurred from the East c.4,000 B.C. Archaeologists have noted evidence on grounds of pottery for an abrupt immigration from the East relatable to earliest Neolithic in the Middle Urals and Soviet Central Asia. There is concrete evidence for an Asian origin of the Indo-Europeans, c.4,500 B.C., and there are attempts to trace the Kurgan people from India. Bernard Sergent stated that researchers are able to ‘trace an Asian origin for the Indo-Europeans well before their dispersion.’ The evidence of the co-existence of two different kind of people could support the idea that the builders of the temples were trying to keep their rituals secret from the indigenous population. Is there evidence that the builders of the temples were sun worshippers? It would be further proof.

Thanking you for your attention,
C. Preston
[email protected]

Something is not right. This message is just to keep things from messing up down the road