Register here - as a registered user you get more features and fewer ads.
The text below is an extract from my biography on L.A. Waddell now entitled RISE OF MAN IN THE GARDENS OF SUMERIA. It's about theories on the origin of the Aryans and Childe's conclusions. The discovery of the megalithic temples may be evidence in favour of these theories. (C. Preston)
Childe and Kossinna:
The first scholar who combined Prehistoric Archaeology with linguistics to find answers on the question of Aryan origins was Gustav Kossinna, an Anthropologist and Philologist (1858-1931), who published 'The Indo-European Question answered archaeologically' in 1902. Kossinna proposed a cradle of German people in North Germany and a homeland for Indo-European languages on the basis of his study of Corded Ware (pottery). V.G. Childe (1893-1957), first holder of the Abercromby Chair of Prehistoric European Arhaeology (1927-46) and director of the Institute of Archaeology at the University of London, a prehistorian and linguist, adopted Kossinna’s approach to explore the relationship between prehistoric European cultures. Because Archaeology was cultural, Childe explored the origin of the Aryans in terms of culture on the evidence of archaeological remains and linguistics. Kossinna had also expounded that the Aryans had reached Mesopotamia as the Sumerians. In Childe’s view this notion would have happily explained the ‘supposed affinity between Sumerian and Indo-European speech.’ After studying material dated to the 4th Millennium B.C. excavated at Ur, Kish, and Erech, in 1922, Childe concluded that it revealed no sign of local development from a primitive state. This indicated that the Sumerian civilization was not indigenous. The civilization had been created by conquerors or newcomers from another nation, who ruled over the local peasantry and glorified their victory by the restoration and enlargement of old shrines to which were connected painted figurines with serpent faces and the Moon god Nannar, a deity with a distinctive matriarchal character. The Sumerians remained nameless and their origin was a mystery. One of the reasons Childe believed they were Aryan was that in records of correspondence preserved at Tell El Amarna, Egypt, the names of the gods princes acknowledged were Indo-Iranian. He had also noted that the Amorites (Phoenicians) were often depicted by the 18th and subsequent Egyptian dynasties, as tall, with blue eyes, brown hair, and relatively fair skin. The archaeologist E. Mackay professed in the late 1940s that Sumerian had evolved from proto-Elamite (a language of Syria, Asia Minor), and that Sumerian and Indus Valley remains indicated a common Proto-Elamite ancestry.
Cradle in Scandinavia or Russia:
Childe’s study of Nordic expansion in The Aryans (1926) is regarded as having put order to European Prehistory. He tried to identify the cradle of the Aryans by reversing Kossinna’s theory and derive the ‘battle-axe folk’ from South Russia instead of Scandinavia. It was a hypothesis first propounded by Professor J.L. Myres and developed by Harold Peake. Central to this theory was a battle-axe which was an exceptional device and recognised by Scandinavian archaeologists as an imitation of the one used by Sumerians by 3,000 B.C. However, at the end of his book, Childe stated that his confidence in the Kurgan (South Russian) hypothesis was shaken ‘since he espoused it,’ and concluded that ‘in default’ only the Germanist theory for the cradle of the Aryans suggested by Kossinna was left and that in this case, Kurgans would not be the earliest Aryans.
Childe admitted that Kossinna’s system was a ‘profound mastery of the archaeological material’ and consisted in the settling down of Palaeolithic hunters, tall Cro-Magnon, in 10,000 B.C. on the shores of lakes in the Baltic, their main centres being Scandinavia, but also an area from Britain to Latvia; then the round-headed and long-headed ancestors of ‘Indo-Germans’ (Aryans) and Finns who spoke an agglutinative tongue from which Indo-European and Finno-Urian languages derived. By 4,000 B.C. some had separated from the homeland. Those who migrated south pronounced ‘k’ (or ‘c’) softly (and were of the linguistic ‘satem’ group). They created the Danubian civilization. The Satem group were driven from the Ukraine towards Greece as Thracians and founded the Minoan civilization. Some went east and those left on the Baltic coast and North Sea built dolmens, then North-Indo-Germans, warriors at the same time as pastoralists, cultivators and navigators sent out waves of conquering colonists. The Germanist School expounded that the folks who lived on the Baltic, North Sea, Denmark, Sweden and Norway, were visited by navigators from the South-West seeking the source of amber. These could have been Phoenicians navigating from Phoenicia across the Mediterranean Sea, passing by Gibraltar, and continuing North along the coast of Spain and France until they reached the British Isles, and then continued to Scandinavia. On Kossinna’s chronology, before 3,000 B.C., pioneers spread westward along the North Sea and down to the Danubian region.
Something is not right. This message is just to keep things from messing up down the road


