Register here - as a registered user you get more features and fewer ads.
Andy, as an archaeologist that lives and works in Lewis, I take your point, lots of archaeology will be discovered. However, I don't believe this would necessarily be a good thing, and I would prefer not to benefit myself. As you say yourself, the important issue is the birds, the fish, all the living things. If the view will look bad, its because it will represent the devastation of a pristine landscape- and the ways in which it will do this are too numerous to mention.
Also, there is a problem in the way that the planning regs work - big developers get big archaeological contractors, and their work is, in my opinion, compromised by their wish to get more contracts from big developers, and because their people are brought in from afar, to work in the "middle of no-where", with absolutely no personal attachment.
Its often said that the moors are nothingness, but it is only true when looking from afar. People indigenous to these islands have names for every little bump and puddle across this nothingness, and its uses are numerous!
I cant help but feel that if we let large multinationals rape places in the name of environmentalism than we will surely re-produce the problem in a new setting. This is a bad quick fix. Lewis should not have to give up its vitality to power more over consumption in the big cities.
I thank you for your site and opportunity to communicate!
Ian Mchardy
ps. the windfarm that threatens the Cailleach na Mointeach is a separate development, and is still likely to go ahead.. Please help!
Something is not right. This message is just to keep things from messing up down the road


