Register here - as a registered user you get more features and fewer ads.
The Government this week put forward new plans for the protection of archaeological sites on agricultural lands.
The heritage white paper suggests existing consents which allow sites to be cultivated could be withdrawn in favour of individual management agreements.
But agricultural agencies are concerned the scheme will not be properly funded and many farmers are worried they will be left out of pocket
The South West is rich in archaeological sites and Bodmin Moor has more than its fair share.
Most are open to public access, but this is also working agricultural land.
Steve Nankivell's family have been farming on the 2300-acre Hamatethy Common for four generations... and it is a delicate balance.
Stewardship scheme
Many farmers are paid to look after the land rather than to work it.
Steve is one of 35 commoners here signed up to the Countryside Stewardship Scheme to preserve the natural habitat and prevent overgrazing.
Effectively they are compensated by DEFRA for restrictions imposed on how many animals they can graze on the moor and when - but that can lead to problems when it comes to protecting the many ancient sites.
"There's an ancient field system on the side of Roughtor. DEFRA wanted us to spray a 2ha area to keep down the growth.
It cost us £900 to do it and we got back £300 in grants. That put us £600 in costs - costs we can't bear" said Steve.
Ancient fort
Clarence Paull has an ancient fort on his farm near Fowey. Castle Dore is thought to date back to 300BC and was an important site in the Civil War.
It was overgrown with brambles when he took on the farm in 1957 and clearing it has been a huge job.
At one time Clarence used to cultivate the land in and around the fort to grow cauliflower... but it has been set aside for some years and he now qualifies for grant aid to help maintain the site.
"I think minimum wage is somewhere around £2.50 an hour, I probably receive closer to 25 pence an hour" he said.
"But that's not to say I don't appreciate it. It does help and I love to see the site a bit more cared for."
Class consents
Some farmers have been allowed to continue cultivating heritage sites under voluntary agreements known as class consents.
The consents were based on research which suggested ploughing at the same depth did not damage the archaeology beneath.
But in its Heritage White Paper published this week the Department for Culture, Media and Sport, says that has changed:
"Research by DEFRA and English Heritage has shown... that such cultivation causes damage to a significant number of scheduled ancient monuments...
"We will reform the current system based on a management agreement approach."
Scheme under funded?
The National Farmers Union says the last thing farmers want to do is to damage ancient monuments.
It is concerned English Heritage will not receive sufficient funding to support the scheme. And it is not alone.
"We want to examine this White Paper," said Shadow Culture Media and Sport Secretary Hugo Swire MP.
"We want to make sure that funding is there otherwise its empty rhetoric and there is nothing worse than asking farmers to comply with something which isn't properly enforced and funded - that would be a waste of everyone's time!"
The Department for Culture, Media and Sport is inviting consultations on the contents of the White Paper by the 01 June 2007.
It says class consents will only be withdrawn on individual sites if a management agreement is first offered and it says agreements will make use of existing schemes wherever possible.
It also says the agreements will be designed to last for 10 years - ensuring our heritage is preserved way beyond the foreseeable future.
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/programmes/politics_show/6446513.stm
Something is not right. This message is just to keep things from messing up down the road


